AICPA President, CEO and former Mr. Universe Barry Melancon, CPA, CGMA wrote a letter to […]
Tag: Feedback
EY Employees Embarking on Annual Make Passive Aggressive Suggestions for Improvement Ritual
It’s review time! Seeking #feedback from your team throughout the year is an #effective way […]
Take the Going Concern Annual Reader Survey to Save the Children*
It's that time of year again when the publishing overlords who run this laugh factory […]
This Is a Friendly Reminder to Take the Going Concern Jobs Survey and Enter for a Chance to Win an iPad Mini
Hey, everyone. Colin here. Mind if I pull you away from your spreadsheets for a […]
Another List of the Best Accounting Firms to Work For, And Another Reason to Hate These Lists
If you hate your job, it's clearly because you don't work for one of Accounting […]
Here Are the Going Concern Freelancer Finalists
After a grueling first round, we've narrowed the field down to three. We took a […]
CPA Review Students: We Want Feedback on Your Study Program
Hey folks, a concerned reader reached out the other day to vent about their current […]
I See What You Did There: The Latest Changes on Going Concern
Well, if it isn't another mopey March Monday in busy season. If your life has […]
Occupy the SEC Sends a 325 Page Comment Letter On the Volcker Rule
Ah, the Volcker Rule… an allegedly sublime piece of legislation that keeps the Goldman rats […]
Your Thoughts on the New Going Concern
So now that we've opened the kimono, TPTB are pretty anxious to know what you […]
Partner Criticizes Subordinate for Dressing Like Peasant, Eating Like a Wild Beast
For the most part, performance reviews are a fairly disappointing affair. You walk in, prepared to explain why you’re such a badass CPA only to be informed that you’re pretty average. It’s nothing personal, it’s just that your auditing/tax/advisory skills could use some improvement and there are many, many other people that deserve more money than you. For whatever reason, occasionally a performance counselor will take the opportunity in the review process to get a little personal. Feedback like, “Personal hygiene needs work,” or “Dresses like a slob,” or “Sucks as a human being,” is hardly constructive but has been known to happen. This morning we have yet another example of someone getting a little nasty.
Here’s our recipient/tipster:
I have gotten some interesting evaluations by the Partner in my office over the last couple of years. I would be curious to know if other public accountants get the same amount of candid feedback that my partner is willing to provide. Here is a sample of what I received on a recent evaluation:
“I have also commented to ___ on his professional dress. It appears he was compliant with firm policy regarding attire without collars, but I must admit that the overall choice was on the very low scale of professional dress. I believe ___ has taken action to correct this matter and I encourage him to “dress for success.” I also encourage ___ to place greater emphasis on proper table manners. In particular, not eating french fries with your hands while with a client at a nice restaurant.
Our tipster explains that his dress “was a nice, crew neck sweater with brown slacks, [the partner] was pissed off that there was no collar. I sent him an email with the firm dress policy to prove that it was within the guidelines.”
But really, our reader admits, “the french fry comment is the best. The restaurant was middle-tier at best.”
As our reader said, he’s looking for similar stories, so if you’ve been admonished for rocking a turtleneck or ignoring your knife and fork, share your stories below. And then you should feel shame. SHAME.