October 24, 2021

Elizabeth Warren Shocked to Learn Big Public Accounting Firms Do Shady Sh*t

Uh-oh, the Big 4 firms have gotten Sen. Elizabeth Warren’s dander up.

The Massachusetts Democrat was appalled at a recent New York Times report that found at least 35 examples of big public accounting firm tax lawyers who left to join the US Treasury’s tax policy office or other government positions and then were rehired by their old firm. In nearly half of those cases, the employees were promoted to partner upon their return—often doubling their pay.

What drew Warren’s ire was how these ex-PA tax lawyers were able to approve generous tax loopholes that were often used by their former firms, give tax breaks to former clients, and roll back efforts to rein in tax shelters while working inside the US government, according to the report. The NYT wrote:

The largest U.S. accounting firms have perfected a remarkably effective behind-the-scenes system to promote their interests in Washington. Their tax lawyers take senior jobs at the Treasury Department, where they write policies that are frequently favorable to their former corporate clients, often with the expectation that they will soon return to their old employers. The firms welcome them back with loftier titles and higher pay, according to public records reviewed by The New York Times and interviews with current and former government and industry officials. …

After lobbying by PwC, a former PwC partner in the Trump Treasury Department helped write regulations that allowed large multinational companies to avoid tens of billions of dollars in taxes; he then returned to PwC. A senior executive at another major accounting firm, RSM, took a top job at Treasury, where his office expanded a tax break in ways sought by RSM; he then returned to the firm.

The thing is, this has been going on at the Big 4 for a long time. A Redditor commented about the NYT article: “And in other news, water is wet.” But now, thanks to the Times, this gaming of the system is now out in the open.

Apparently Warren couldn’t believe how sneaky and shady the Big 4 (and RSM) really are, so she and House Rep. Pramila Jayapa (D-WA) decided that sending letters to the CEOs of Deloitte, PwC, EY, KPMG, and RSM tsk-tsking them over this scheme will get them to stop. But if that doesn’t work, Warren and Jayapa threatened to stop it via an ethics bill they introduced in Congress in both 2018 and 2020.

The letter states: “Americans are sick and tired of these corrupt schemes, and we’ve introduced the AntiCorruption and Public Integrity Act (S. 5070) that would end them. The decades-long scam in which large accounting firms have abused the revolving door between the government and the private sector to help their wealthy clients avoid paying their fair share of taxes demonstrates precisely why this legislation is necessary.”

Here is the full text of one of the letters Warren and Jayapa sent to the five accounting firms. This is the one Deloitte CEO Joe Ucuzoglu received:

Joe Ucuzoglu
Chief Executive Officer
Deloitte US
30 Rockefeller Plaza
New York, NY 10112

Dear Mr. Ucuzoglu:

We write regarding a disturbing new report that reveals the corrupt revolving door between the world’s largest accounting firms and the federal government—and the extent to which this “remarkably effective behind-the-scenes system” “help[s] the world’s biggest companies avoid taxes.” On September 19, 2021, the New York Times exposed how large accounting firms—including Deloitte—send their lawyers into high-ranking positions in the federal government to create new tax loopholes for their clients, and then reward the same lawyers with bigger paychecks and promotions upon their return. We are seeking information to understand the extent to which Deloitte has been involved in these unethical schemes.

Accounting giants are abusing the public trust and taking advantage of the revolving door between public service and private profit. The Times report uncovers that, in the last four presidential administrations, dozens of lawyers have left the top accounting firms for tax-policy positions in the Treasury Department and the Internal Revenue Service—where they have rewritten America’s tax laws for the benefit of their former clients. Once they return after their stints in government to work for those same clients, they receive promotions and massive salary increases in exchange for their “public service.”

In one instance, Deloitte and PricewaterhouseCoopers designed a lucrative new tax shelter for multinational corporations, which was placed at risk when the Treasury Department issued a warning notice to shut down the scheme. But several years later, a former Deloitte attorney entered the Treasury Department, and his office issued new regulations to ease the path for companies shifting their profits offshore to avoid U.S. taxes. The attorney soon returned to Deloitte and was immediately promoted to partner.

Americans are sick and tired of these corrupt schemes, and we’ve introduced the AntiCorruption and Public Integrity Act (S. 5070) that would end them. The decades-long scam in which large accounting firms have abused the revolving door between the government and the private sector to help their wealthy clients avoid paying their fair share of taxes demonstrates precisely why this legislation is necessary. Under our bill:

  • Executive branch employees would be required to recuse themselves from matters that might financially benefit their immediately prior employers or clients
  • Private-sector companies would be restricted from immediately hiring or paying any senior government official that was recently lobbied by the company
  • The world’s largest corporations, banks, and monopolies would be restricted from immediately hiring or paying any senior government official after they leave government service
  • Private-sector companies would be banned from providing “golden parachutes” to compensate executives for entering into federal service
  • Lobbyists would be required to disclose any specific government actions that they attempted to influence, any meetings conducted with public officials, and any documents provided to those government officials
  • A new U.S. Office of Public Integrity would be created to enforce federal ethics and anticorruption laws

Our legislation would close the revolving door between massive accounting firms like yours and the federal government, ensuring that our government officials work for the people and not the wealthiest corporations and their clients. And Sen. Warren’s Real Corporate Profits Tax, which would simplify the tax system and make it harder for giant corporations to create and profit from tax loopholes, would reduce the payoff from these unethical practices and the incentives to engage in them.

To better understand Deloitte’s participation in the corrupt revolving door scheme detailed by the New York Times, we ask that you answer the following questions by October 19, 2021:

1. Since January 1, 2001, how many lawyers or other Deloitte employees have taken tax policy positions in the Treasury Department, the IRS, or elsewhere in the federal government and returned to Deloitte after their government service?

2. For each of these employees, please provide the following information:

a. When they left Deloitte, and when they returned.
b. What position(s) they served in at Deloitte, before and after their government service, and what their specific responsibilities were in those positions.
c. What position(s) they served in in the federal government, and what their specific responsibilities were in those positions, including any regulatory or legislative matters they worked on that affected Deloitte clients.
d. Who their clients at Deloitte were, before and after their government service.
e. Their compensation at Deloitte, before and after their government service, and any bonuses or other compensation they received in relation to their government service.

3. What are Deloitte’s policies to guard against conflicts of interest for employees who formerly worked for the federal government? Specifically, are Deloitte employees allowed to retain clients if they worked on matters related to these clients while serving in the federal government?

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

Sincerely,

Elizabeth Warren
United States Senator

Pramila Jayapa
Member of Congress

Warren and Jayapa can send all the letters they want to the Big 4, but the fact is nothing is gonna change. Their ethics bill probably won’t get the support it needs in Congress (it hasn’t even left the Senate Finance Committee) before the 2022 election to be enacted into law— and it definitely won’t if the Dems lose control of either the House and/or the Senate next year. And there’s no way the Big 4 and RSM and whatever other firms are doing this (probably BDO and Grant Thornton too) will stop gaming the system if it benefits them and their clients.

But good effort, tho, Liz and Pramila.

How Accounting Giants Craft Favorable Tax Rules From Inside Government [New York Times]

Latest Accounting Jobs--Apply Now:

Have something to add to this story? Give us a shout by email, Twitter, or text/call the tipline at 202-505-8885. As always, all tips are anonymous.

4 Comments

  1. Hipocrats. Warren and her buddies make the laws and are supposed to supervise the administration. They should send this letter to themselves for how shitty they did their jobs.
    Shows again how politicians are useless and populists.

    1. This may be the stupidest thing I’ve read all day.

      “I’m going to vote for people who don’t want to regulate anything, then complain about people who want to regulate either overregulate or don’t regulate enough….whichever makes my party look better.”

      And..

      “You are attempting to regulate. How useless you are because you didn’t do it already.”

      Remove the rectum from your cranium.

      Yes, most politicians are usually useless and populists. You got that right, at least. But your comment makes them look smart

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Related articles

Friday Footnotes: Deloitte Complains Its Way to a Contract; Deficiencies Abound; Beyond the Windowless Audit Room | 10.22.21

How CPAs can rise above a polarized political climate [Journal of Accountancy] Aside from being prepared for these possible changes, [Publisher and editor-in-chief of The Cook Political Report Amy] Walter recommends that CPAs break away from the polarization that has made each side feel like an election is an existential fight for the real America. […]