Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Auditors Not Being Credited with “Better Letter Than Never” in Discovery of Pennsylvania School District’s $15 Million Error

In yesterday's Footnotes, we mentioned that the Reading, Pennsylvania School District sorta overstated the amount of a subsidy that it received from the Keystone State. An unfortunate error that will likely result in cutbacks for another struggling school district. 

Because the children are being wronged here, there is plenty of outrage and blamestorming going around. And since we're dealing with financial reporting, the first line of attack in the firestorm of blame is the external auditors. Take it away Reading school district CFO:
Chief Financial Officer Robert Peters explained that the mistake occurred at the end of the 2010-11 school year when a district employee erroneously recorded an extra payment from the state. The mistake made it appear that the district received nearly $16 million more than it actually did, he said.
That fall, the error slipped past auditors from Barbacane, Thornton and Co., who were doing the district's annual audit.
"It should have been caught by the auditors," Peters said.
Okay, sure. This resulted in the district submitting misstated financial statements to the Department of Education, who missed the error, and a special task force assigned to review the district's finances didn't find it either. But the auditors! Come on, BT & Co.! Where were you?
[The mistake] finally came to light last fall after Barbacane, Thornton and Co. performed an audit on the 2011-12 school year.
Not event the slightest bit of credit or appreciation. Rough.

Latest Accounting Jobs--Apply Now:

Have something to add to this story? Give us a shout by email, Twitter, or text/call the tipline at 202-505-8885. As always, all tips are anonymous.

Related articles

Broken lightbulb isolated on white

Kill the Audit Industry, Says Ex-Auditor

In the WaPo opinion pages yesterday one Duncan Mavin, who got his start in the 90s, says the best way to solve the audit industry’s many conflicts is to kill it altogether. He starts the piece summoning the ghost of Enron, as all writers do when discussing what happens when audit goes wrong. Bringing things […]

Treasure chest on the beach

KPMG Gets Sued, Accused of Allowing Pirate-Like Activity at Credit Suisse

Discountenanced Credit Suisse stockholder Gregory Stevenson is suing 29 of Credit Suisse’s current and former directors and officers, the bank’s ex-auditor KPMG, and various KPMG henchmen on behalf of investors alleging the firm looked the other way while aforementioned directors and officers plundered the bank for more than a decade. The docket number is No. […]