Related Posts
The Number of Financial Statement Audit Deficiencies Is Blowing Up
- Caleb Newquist
- June 6, 2012
So says an analysis of PCAOB inspection report data: The Survey of Fair Value Audit […]
The Truth About Public Accounting, Part II: PCAOB Inspection Hysteria — How to Fix It
- Robert Conway
- February 5, 2021
While there is a consensus that the PCAOB’s existence has improved audit quality, it is […]
You Can Add ‘Hospital Staff’ to the List of Positions That Can Do the Job of a Deloitte Auditor
- Caleb Newquist
- June 7, 2011
A hospital in Winnipeg is suing Deloitte after an ATM scam went undiscovered for over ten years. Luckily some vigilant RN, janitor or cafeteria worker (it’s not clear from the article) noticed something amiss and alerted the proper authorities.
Police arrested a long-time hospital employee last year after she allegedly skimmed $1.5 million from automated teller machine (ATM) deposits between 2000 and 2010.
According to a lawsuit filed last week, the fraud was uncovered by hospital staff, not the auditor. The lawsuit accuses Deloitte & Touche of preparing financial statements not in accordance with “generally accepted accounting principles” and “materially misleading” the hospital about its financial position.
“MHC says that D & T owed it a duty in contract and owed it a duty of care not to act negligently or make negligent misrepresentations to MHC and to ensure that cash and liquid assets as reported in the financial statements were not materially misstated.”
According to the lawsuit, a former finance clerk deposited Worker’s Compensation Board cheques into the hospital operated ATM, understated the amount and pocketed the difference.
All this trouble and no one was even taken hostage. Not good, Green Dot.
Misericordia Health Centre files suit against auditor [Winnipeg Sun]
