Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
September 27, 2023

Anyone Who Actually Believes This Spam Is From the AICPA Deserves To Lose Their CPA License

A tipster sent us a frantic suggestion that the AICPA member list may have been "hacked" but after about 3 minutes of digging (let no one say we're lazy journalists), we easily debunked the emails in question as general spam and nothing for AICPA members to be worried about. If a biologist is getting the emails, chances are it's some bored Nigerian in an Internet cafe and not an Anonymous plan to dismantle the public accounting industry from the inside.

That said, just in case any AICPA members receive the suspicious email and actually feel their good standing in the profession is at risk, be on the lookout for this:

We have received a complaint about your alleged involvement in tax return fraudulent activity for one of your employees. According to AICPA Bylaw Subsection 730 your Certified Public Accountant license can be cancelled in case of the occurrence of presenting of a false or fraudulent income tax return on the member's or a client's behalf. Please be notified below and provide your feedback to it within 14 days. The failure to respond within this term will result in withdrawal of your Accountant status.

Now, the first tip off here (besides the slightly awkward use of English and random capitalization of the word "Accountant") is the fact that it threatens revocation of a CPA's license based on allegations of tax fraud. As everyone knows, the rule (as far as I understand it) in this country remains innocent until proven guilty. So while allegations of tax fraud may put you on some AICPA watch list, it's pretty safe to assume your license is not in jeopardy simply because the IRS has begun fraud proceedings against you. Note for the remedial crowd: that doesn't mean it's ever OK to lie on your or anyone else's taxes, but allegations take awhile to turn into charges.

The funny part about this confusing, virus-laden piece of spam is that it cites the correct AICPA bylaw, which states that membership in the Institute shall be suspended or terminated without a hearing for disciplinary purposes, or a member may be subjected to other disciplinary actions, as provided in sections 7.3.1 and 7.3.2, under such conditions and by such procedure as shall be prescribed by the Council. Sections 7.3.1 and 7.3.2 basically state that if an AICPA member commits a crime subject to imprisonment for more than one year, he or she can pretty much assume they will not be an AICPA member any longer, and that willful failure to file a tax return or filing a fraudulent tax return is also going to get a person's AICPA membership revoked, but again, that would require an investigation by the IRS before it comes to that. Filing false tax returns for clients will also receive the same treatment.

SO, the moral of the story here is that if you get this email, don't trip, you're still an outstanding representative of the profession, your activity on this site notwithstanding.


Latest Accounting Jobs--Apply Now:

Have something to add to this story? Give us a shout by email, Twitter, or text/call the tipline at 202-505-8885. As always, all tips are anonymous.

Comments are closed.

Related articles

a student taking a nap on a bench

Withum’s Solution to the War on Talent Is to Throw Students Onto the Battlefield

Adamant that there is no way the burden of 150 units for CPA licensure will ever be rolled back to 120, the AICPA and NASBA have scored a second school-firm collaboration for their CPA Pathway Apprenticeship initiative: Seton Hall University and Withum. The program trades work in the field for credits toward 150. From Withum’s […]

large empty lecture hall

What Would the Accreditors Say About AICPA’s ELE Program?

By Sharon Lassar, PhD, CPA (Florida) John J. Gilbert Professor and Director of the School of Accountancy, University of Denver Last week I raised the question of whether it is ethical to promote an educational path to CPA licensure that is (highly) susceptible to cheating. The AICPA’s pipeline acceleration plan proposes an Experience, Learn & […]